Sputnik or Trojan Whale?

Professor Brian Keating
6 min readFeb 5, 2025

DeepSeek: A Trojan Horse in Disguise

DeepSeek is the Trojan horse of today. It looks like a gift — free, powerful, and helpful. But once inside, it doesn’t sit still. It gains root access to your devices and digs into your private life. Like any Trojan, once it’s there, it can’t be fully removed. And here’s the truth: if you aren’t paying for the product, you are the product. Your keystrokes. Your conversations. Your habits. They aren’t just data — they’re currency for companies to exploit, not protect.

DeepSeek: A Spy Balloon Disguised as an AI Titan

In a world obsessed with tech, DeepSeek’s rise feels familiar. It started with chaos and panic. But it didn’t last long. Its journey isn’t a Sputnik moment. It’s more like the Chinese spy balloon: a brief frenzy, overblown claims, and a hard look at hidden weaknesses we can’t afford to ignore.

Inflated Threats: Hype Meets Reality

At first, the market freaked out. Tech stocks plunged. Nvidia lost $593 billion overnight. But just like the balloon scare, DeepSeek’s big claims fell apart under pressure. Reality hit. It always does.

Questionable Claims: Promises That Don’t Hold Up

Security Concerns

DeepSeek wasn’t just flawed. It was a disaster. Over a million lines of sensitive data — things like software keys and internal logs — were left exposed. Worse, it failed every major security test. U.S.-based AI systems, even the basic ones, performed better. These gaps weren’t small. They were canyons.

Cost Claims: A Mirage of Efficiency

DeepSeek bragged about its $5 million development cost. But tech expert Palmer Luckey wasn’t fooled. He called it misleading. Why? They left out key expenses like infrastructure and labor. It’s like claiming you built a house for $100,000 but forgetting the cost of land and materials. It’s not just wrong — it’s deceptive.

Strategic Impact: Exposing Broader Weaknesses

The spy balloon showed flaws in U.S. air defenses. DeepSeek did the same for AI development and chip export controls. Texas acted fast, banning it on government devices. Congress followed, pushing for tighter export restrictions. The lesson? This isn’t about one app. It’s about how easily our systems can be infiltrated and exploited.

Why Protection Measures Aren’t Enough

Core Vulnerabilities

Even with VPNs and burner emails, DeepSeek is dangerous. It failed to block harmful prompts. Then it faced major cyberattacks that exposed even more weaknesses. When defenses fail this easily, the platform isn’t a tool. It’s a threat.

Data Collection Concerns

DeepSeek tracks everything. Even if you take precautions, it still logs:

  • Keystroke patterns
  • Device IDs and system data
  • User inputs and chat histories

This isn’t an accident. It’s the design. You’re not using the tool — you’re feeding it.

A Trojan Horse Wrapped as a Gift

DeepSeek looks free. But it comes with a cost. Like a Trojan horse, it sneaks into your devices and roots itself in your private life. Once inside, it’s almost impossible to remove. Here’s the catch: if you’re not paying for the product, you arethe product. Your keystrokes, habits, and messages aren’t just stored. They’re sold.

Government Control Factor: The Illusion of Privacy

In China, no company is truly private. DeepSeek is legally required to share its data with the government. As cybersecurity expert Pearl says, its privacy policy means nothing. Privacy isn’t real here. It’s a lie that breaks when it’s convenient.

What Should You Do?

Privacy experts all agree. Don’t use DeepSeek. For government workers or anyone handling sensitive data, this isn’t advice — it’s a necessity. No VPN or burner account can protect you from data stored on servers controlled by a foreign regime.

Final Thought

Don’t panic. But don’t be naive. Think critically. Protect yourself. Every new tool tests how well we balance convenience and security.

Wrap your digital life with care. If you don’t pay your’re the product. set your price accordinging. And make sure you Look those gift horses in the mouth!

Until next time, have a M.A.G.I.C. Week,

Brian

Appearance

Huge news! I just got invited back on Star Talk! In case you missed it, check out my first appearance.

Genius

Astronomers using JWST in an AAS press conference.

Jacob Jencson (Caltech/IPAC) and Joshua Peek (Space Telescope Science Institute) showed what a difference aperture makes. New James Webb Space Telescope images reveal hidden structures in the interstellar medium within the Cassiopeia A supernova remnant. Occurring in the late 17th century, Cas A remains a treasure trove for astronomers, demonstrating how new technology can uncover secrets even in well-studied cosmic objects. At last week’s American Astronomical Society meeting, scientists highlighted how these findings illuminate the fine structure of dusty gas, potentially forming future stars and offering unexpected advancements in understanding the Milky Way’s stellar birthplaces.

“Structure like this has never been seen before,” says Jencson. “We were pretty shocked to see this level of detail.”

Image

Don’t worry — you’ve still got time to see all the planets.

Not only that, but in the coming 10 days the waxing Moon will pair up with all of them, starting with Saturn on January 31st and finishing up with Mars on February 9th.

Conversation

In this interview, I sit down with Richard Panek to discuss his book Pillars of Creation and the groundbreaking discoveries of the James Webb Space Telescope. We dive into the controversy surrounding early JWST data, which challenged our understanding of galaxy formation and even sparked debate about the Big Bang. Richard explains how science refines theories with new data, offering a fascinating look at the process.

We also explore the incredible engineering behind JWST, the challenges of its launch, and what the future holds for space telescopes. Plus, we break down how JWST’s stunning infrared images are colorized and what’s next in the quest to understand dark matter, dark energy, and relativity.

Don’t miss this deep dive into the universe’s biggest mysteries!

Click here to watch!

Advertisement

Acorns Early is the smart money app and debit card for kids that helps kids learn the value of money.

Parents can use the Acorns Early app to track their kids’ chores and pay allowance automatically, while kids can set savings goals, take interactive learning courses about all things money, and spend what they’ve earned with their very own debit card.

Upcoming Episode

Dava Sobel will be on The INTO THE IMPOSSIBLE Podcast soon. As a celebrated author known for her bestsellers like Longitude and Galileo’s Daughter, Sobel has a unique talent for bringing the stories of scientific pioneers to life, making complex subjects accessible and engaging for all readers. Her latest work, The Elements of Marie Curie, not only chronicles the life of the iconic scientist but also highlights the contributions of women in science, showcasing Sobel’s commitment to illuminating underrepresented narratives in history. What questions do you have for Dava Sobel that you’d like us to explore during the podcast?

--

--

Professor Brian Keating
Professor Brian Keating

Written by Professor Brian Keating

Chancellor’s Distinguished Professor at UC San Diego. Host of The INTO THE IMPOSSIBLE Podcast Authored: Losing the Nobel Prize & Think like a Nobel Prize Winner

No responses yet